Seek Rivalry, Not Enmity

The election of 2016 did nothing to sate the hunger of ultranationalists.  It was instead fuel to the flames of domestic extremism, as much a validation of their values and doctrine as a confirmation of their perceived under- or even unrepresented state among the political elite.  For just as much as they might prefer one candidate to the other side’s, they regard all politicians as disconnected plutocrats.

            When a system suffers a loss of confidence in its very fabric, the realization of its largely ethereal nature may become dangerously apparent.  Such is the case with any number of “economic bubbles,” but when such an affliction comes to infect a system of governance, the presumed stability of what seemed eternal at once is seen for what it truly is.  What recourse is there in the event that the institutions which are meant to structure and bind society to itself is regarded with suspicion by those to whom it is meant to serve?

            History has shown that realization—the ethereal nature of all things sustained primarily by public confidence—comes only in the midst of revolution, notably past the point at which such catastrophes might be avoided.  For peaceful transitions are rare, and often lead to places that may not be desirable, as the collapse of the Soviet Union has demonstrated.  In this case in particular, the solution has not been to conserve the conditions under which the transformation occurred, but instead revenant.  Russia’s goals within her former Soviet sphere of influence can be accurately described as unconventional and revisionist.  It this precisely this latter characterization which has come to permeate the minds of the present generation, a nostalgia that only be measured on a sociocultural scale, one which exceeds the bounds of nation and economic strata.  There is at present a mindset that in the past lie the answers to the present and likewise thence the future.  Thus, when presented with challenges in creativity, a popular response is a direct “reboot” of a preexisting idea, but where perhaps the original carried some measure of novel creativity, a reboot often has more flare than substance.

            But when revisionism becomes part of the political culture, that is when ideologies come to blows.  In the case of the present crisis, ideologies have become bound up in a rhetoric framed in terms of values and rights.  Such ignition of the conversation—however possibly necessary for progress—is alarming for it inherently leads to the opposition being regarded not as rivals, but as enemies.  Enemies should not—cannot be fellow countrymen, might go the logic.  This point is reached in a mere generation, where moralized political disagreements become personalized through the compounding of time and media on any given matter.  The basis of entire news outlets has become the opposition of the other.

            Once we regard our fellow countrymen as enemies, as though in conflict, the conditions for civil war have been met.  There need not be armed factions on either side for violence to erupt.  One side in the present crisis is far more heavily armed than the other, and the very presence of weapons is a threat of violence unto itself.  If such armed conflict beings to coalesce around “mere” lack of confidence in public institutions, then there is little to stop not open disagreement, but even a narrow decision, from becoming the flashpoint of a greater conflagration.

            Amid the rhetoric of patriotism in 2002-03 as we prepared to invade Iraq, I wrote a story of a generation passing before the rhetoric leveled as fellow countrymen would magnify.  In that story, entitled “Imperium Americanum,” I wrote of a two-year civil war concluding in a benevolent military autocracy coming to power to settle the fires of civil war in the United States once and for all.  That fictional civil war took place from 2023 to 2025.

We must remember above all things our humanity and the humanity of those around us. Even those we may dislike or even despise.

27...Love your enemies, do good to those who hate you, 28bless those who curse you, pray for those who abuse you. 29To one who strikes you on the cheek, offer the other also, and from one who takes away your cloak do not withhold your tunic either. 30Give to everyone who begs from you, and from one who takes away your goods do not demand them back. 31And as you wish that others would do to you, do so to them.
Luke 6:27-31 (ESV)

About the Author

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

You may also like these

css.php